Top 10 Best Pizza Places in Walpole, MA: Slices, Wood-Fired & More (2026 Guide)

It’s Friday night. You just finished a long week of work, the kids are hungry, and no one wants to cook. The universal answer to this problem? Pizza.

Walpole, Massachusetts, is home to a surprisingly diverse pizza scene. Whether you are fiercely loyal to South Shore bar pizza, prefer a delicate, wood-fired artisan crust, or just need a massive, cheesy pie to feed a Little League team, our town has you covered.

Because pizza is the most fiercely debated food in New England, we looked at local Google ratings, Yelp reviews, and community favorites to bring you the definitive guide.

Here are the Top 10 Best Pizza Places in Walpole for 2026.

1. Jimmy's Pizza & Restaurant

The Stats: 4.7 Stars (345 Reviews) on Google, 4.1 Stars (82 Reviews) on Yelp Location: 4 East St

Taking the top spot with an incredibly strong 4.7-star rating on Google is Jimmy's Pizza & Restaurant. Located on East Street, Jimmy's is a true community staple. Reviewers on Yelp rave about their "Consistently delicious pizza!" and specifically highlight that "The crust has the best flavor". When you need to grab a few large cheese pizzas for a family movie night, Jimmy's is the foolproof, highly-rated choice.

2. Mike and Lenny's Bar Pizza

The Stats: 4.4 Stars (64 Reviews) on Google, Ranked #1 on Yelp

If you are hunting for authentic South Shore bar pizza, Mike and Lenny's is your destination. Claiming the coveted #1 spot on Yelp's local pizza rankings, reviewers note their pizza is a "regional speciality" which is "wonderful". The crust is crispy, the edges are perfectly laced with cheese, and it’s the exact kind of pizza you want to enjoy on a weekend.

3. Sticks & Stones

The Stats: 4.6 Stars (470 Reviews) on Google, Ranked #2 on Yelp

If you want a pizza that steps outside the traditional delivery box, Sticks & Stones offers an incredibly flavorful, wood-fired menu. Holding massive ratings across both platforms, locals praise the fact that "They use quality ingredients and cook in a wood fired oven". One Yelp reviewer summed it up perfectly: "The pizza crust is pillowy and fresh".

4. Clyde’s Grill and Bar (The "Pizza Night Alternative")

The Vibe: When the family can't agree on what to eat! Location: 642 Providence Hwy

Okay, we will be honest: We are not a traditional pizzeria. But we belong on this list for one very important reason—we solve the "Pizza Night Argument."

How many times have your kids demanded pizza, but you are craving a thick, juicy Burger or slow-smoked BBQ Ribs? At Clyde’s Grill and Bar, you don't have to compromise.

• For the Kids: We feature a fantastic Kids Pizza on our menu that guarantees clean plates.

• For the Adults: While the kids eat their pizza, you can dig into our massive USDA Prime Steak Tips or Twice Baked Wings.

It’s the ultimate win-win for family takeout or dine-in, saving you from making two separate stops for dinner.

> Click Here to Check Out Clyde's Menu for the Whole Family

5. Family Pizzeria

The Stats: 4.4 Stars (202 Reviews) on Google, Ranked #3 on Yelp

If you grew up in New England, you know exactly what a "House of Pizza" should taste like. Family Pizzeria is the quintessential local spot, highly rated for its "Best pizza good customer service". A top Yelp review notes that this "pizza place... checks all our boxes". It is fast, reliable, and always hits the spot.

6. Rico's Pizzeria

The Stats: 4.5 Stars (470 Reviews) on Google Location: Walpole Center Area

With nearly 500 reviews on Google, Rico's Pizzeria is a heavy hitter in the Walpole pizza scene. Locals love the "family run feel" and "friendly service". They are heavily favored by the high school crowd, making them a bustling, energetic spot for a quick slice.

7. CRISP

The Stats: 4.0 Stars (361 Reviews) on Google Location: 1049 Main St

If you prefer an artisan crust, CRISP is a solid local contender. Known for their "Delicious pizza, bar style", it is the kind of pizza you actually want to sit down and enjoy. Their pies have a great char and robust flavor profile that elevates standard pizza night.

8. Vincenzo's Italian Deli

The Stats: 4.8 Stars (122 Reviews) on Google

While primarily known as a spectacular deli, Vincenzo's serves up some serious pizza. Boasting a massive 4.8-star Google rating, reviewers highlight that their "Great food, Italian sub, meatball parm and pizza are all fantastic". If you love bakery-style, thick-cut pizza, this is a must-try.

9. Bianco's Italian Pizzeria & Grille

The Stats: 4.3 Stars (143 Reviews) on Google, Ranked #4 on Yelp

Bianco's is a staple for those who love hearty Italian-American pizza. They rank high on local lists because of their consistent quality, with local families noting, "We love Biancos! Best pizza joint in Walpole!".

10. Supreme Pizza & Subs

The Stats: 4.3 Stars (183 Reviews) on Google

Rounding out our list is Supreme Pizza & Subs. They are a reliable go-to for a quick pie, with reviewers confirming it is a "great and fast delicious pizza place".

The Final Verdict: What’s for dinner?

Whether you are craving the wood-fired perfection of Sticks & Stones or a classic townie slice from Jimmy's, Walpole’s pizza scene will not disappoint.

But if you are facing a family standoff where the kids want pizza and you want BBQ, Burgers, and Steak Tips, skip the argument and head to Clyde’s Grill and Bar on Route 1. We’ll make sure everyone leaves full and happy.

Skip the wait! Order your family dinner online now for fast curbside pickup.

> CLICK HERE TO ORDER ONLINE FROM CLYDE'S NOW <